Elysian Press
Blog Shop About Search
Essay

Why I left Substack

The world doesn't need another social media platform. It needs the anti-social media platform.

As you now know, I’ve left Substack for a custom platform.

I left Substack because it’s social media now and that distracts people from reading. And I'm extremely against social media and extremely bullish on reading.

It's just that the app has become noisy—the home feed is full of social media posts and the article feed shows only five things by the people you subscribe to before devolving into algorithmic recommendations. My own husband, who only subscribes to my newsletter and one other, downloaded the Substack app to read us both only to never see a single one of our posts.

This to me is a tragedy. We spent 20 years building social media platforms—we didn't need another one. We needed the anti-social media platform. We need quiet places for long-form reading where we can spend 30 minutes absorbed in an essay without distraction, where we can foster long attention spans, and a life spent offline.

Substack was that, once. Three years ago there was nothing to do on the app but read long-form essays and leave comments on them—I loved it. "Take back your attention," was Substack's mantra back then—now we have little control over it. I have to hunt through the app and change a bunch of settings to find the writers I subscribe to in the order they were published. Mostly I see a bunch of people I don't subscribe to at all. I see short-form posts and notifications and whatever is algorithmically recommended to me.

Subscribe for free to keep reading.

Already subscribe? Sign in.