Elysian Press
Blog Shop About Search

Tom McNabb

Member since November 2023
Collected Comments
Let states choose their federal governmentsPost Nation · 18 Jun 2026
Decentralize America: The case for cities that don't need WashingtonLet Cities Build Utopia · 17 Mar 2026
We should create more US statesThe Elysian Manifesto · 27 Mar 2025
US states should have autonomy—like EU countriesThe Elysian Manifesto · 19 Mar 2025

"To allow the states to tax, we need to repeal the sixteenth amendment." Don't you mean, to prevent the national government from taxing?

Currently, taxing takes place at every level, but the Federal government just has a greater capacity to tax somehow. But it's probably due to the complaint you mentioned: free movement of businesses and capital--no state can even levy much tax without risking capital and business exodus.

The same problem applies to workers. A state taxes higher--fine, it also spends more and attracts businesses that want to hire more workers. But this leads to greater unemployment because the incoming workers displace the local labor force. Why? Because of free movement of people.

Extrapolating this back over to capital and business again: State A raises taxes and increases spending on the commonweal, making said state more attractive for business. Or it cuts spending and services such as education that are producing diminishing returns, making the state lean and attractive to business. This creates... unemployment of businesses and capital competing for the same pie. I give you that more likely than crowding out, crowding in will occur, but we want to cover the risks.

Then, without putting up tariff barriers between the states, we are still stuck with a national version of globalization: the economic unit still isn't the individual state, but instead is the national corporation, just as now, the economic unit is no longer the nation state but exists only in the international gap between the democratic nation states.

Moving away to another topic:
Where will the extra dollars come from to fund taxation in a thriving, growing set of economies except from deficit, or else, coin, spending at the national level. The money being taxed locally: yes it goes right back into the local economies, but don't we need to provide for growth in the money supply? It is true the banks provide this with their credit creation for loan customers, purchases of corporate bonds and so on. But one would have thought the money the national government adds to the money supply is important. Note that prior to QE, when for a while the Federal Reserve "Bank" was, I think, a bit free, our central bank always issued physical currency by buying bonds issued by *the Treasury*. Aside from this limited hangout, paper cash, the U.S. money supply comes from deficit spending and private bank credit. Cut federal spending, and don't we decrease stability in the system by relying solely on private bank credit? Note, the states taxing and spending "merely" recirculates a fixed quantity of money, which, perhaps, doesn't contribute to growth in the supply of dollars, *assuming* that is important. I say, "assuming," because after all, that is how Treasury auctions work in relation to Federal Reserve account balances, and yet, the non-bank money supply is contributed to thereby: I estimate a fifth to a third of domestic cash (bank account) dollars are created by government deficit spending. So it's not minor. Especially, if we consider it as the more stabile portion of dollars.

Ah, but I just stopped reading in the middle to interject! I will continue. A little bit jealous, because your writing ability is pretty smooth by comparison to my own!

19 Mar 2025 · 1 like
Shelf 1 collected
This Sewing Machine Powers AI
Collected essays

No essays collected yet.