Elysian Press
Blog Shop About Search

Victor P DiGiovanni

Member since August 2022
Collected Comments
I quit Spotify—now I buy albums like it's the 90sInternet Sovereignty · 6 Apr 2026

This article was wonderfully-written and thorough as any I've seen on the subject (and I follow this subject intently). It's 1000% right. I started out the article getting inspired and vowing to myself to now start recommitting to personalizing my connection to the art and artists I like.

But...

... as the article kept going, my spirits sunk further and further. I'm not saying this as a negative about the article. But just that you exposed everything about the experience of music (and books and TV and movies) that made streaming so attractive.

Music (and all media) back in the day benefitted from the Scarcity Monoculture. We had limited selection to purchase, and limited sources that played media for free. Radio/MTV for music, Libraries for books. Network/local channels for movies and TV. We all watched and listened to the same stuff. Even if we hated a song or movie or TV show, you heard it a thousand times and had to endure everyone talking about it. How many of us have beloved favorite songs that are only that way because of Stockholm Syndrome? Hated a song the first hundred times we heard it, but on that 101st listen, that little guitar riff near the end gave us a tiny bit of delight and we started listening to that song on purpose and now it sits at the top of our playlist as our favorite song by that artist.

What modern technology has done (and I can’t blame Spotify for this) is destroyed the Scarcity Monoculture. Everyone listens/watches in their own silos at their own pace, to exactly what they want to hear. Even back in the day, “Indie music” was still funneled through the same national/global sources. Even that scene was still built on a massive scarcity foundation. Indie music had much wider exposure and adoption than anything today, even some of the big artists.

As the 90s progressed, if you were a music-head, you evolved with the technology. CDs changed everything! Then the 3-disk CD changer. Then the 200-disk changer! Oh how I loved that thing! And then.. And THEN… the ability to burn our own CD’s. Perfect-quality mixtapes! Now my 200-disk CD changer was turbrocharged with personal greatest hits compilations. All the songs I didn’t like on the individual CDs I no longer had to worry that the randomizer would land on those songs. And THEN… Napster. Napster was my introduction to mp3s. Napster helped me complete the acquisition of ALL my Holy Grail songs that I had spent years scouring used CD bins looking for. I completed my quest that very first night on Napster. And then I digitized my entire collection of CDs (more than a thousand). From that point on, I only bought mp3 players and then leveled up to smartphones and itunes, and then eventually arrived at Spotify as we all did. Spotify did not create this problem. We ALL created this. It’s the natural evolution of what we wanted forever and ever. Access to ALL our media at all times, no matter where we were, on one device. THAT was the Holy Grail. And we achieved it. Spotify. Netflix. Kindle.

We did it, ya’ll. 24/7 access to 100% of my media, in my pocket. We are no longer at the whims of the gatekeepers as to what we listen to. We have total control.

And yet… that’s the disaster. We got what we wanted and it is destroying how we discover and consume media. Turns out we won’t sample an endless string of new, indie music. We’ll listen to the same 3000 songs that we’ve lovingly curated into playlists. I LOVE my playlists. They are exactly what I want. But I’ve added maybe five new artists to my vast roster of musicians in the past twenty years. I no longer even accidentally hear 90% of the top popular songs nowadays even once, much less over and over to where my resistance fades and I realize I like that song or artist after all. The Grammy Awards are a bizarre wonderland of artists I’ve never heard of that are apparently the biggest artists in the world. Granted, I can’t stand hip-hop or rap, so I wasn’t going to discover those artists anyway. Only maybe one song a year makes it out of the silos of those fans and becomes something that I hear just out in the wild enough times to where I recognize it. “Golden” was the only song this year that fits that bill. Barely.

All that to say that the solutions you provided are EXHAUSTING.Yes, there will absolutely be fans, especially younger generations, that will embrace the rebelliousness of this plan. The DIY of it. But it is SO MUCH WORK to do something that used to be so frictionless. And even so, you’re still having to do all the work of making yourself find and listen to artists that you MIGHT like after listening tot he songs a dozen times. In all the examples you suggested, you are still alone there. Yes, you can get involved, but that’s more work on your part.

Music/media discovery is at its most delightful and powerful when it’s organic and part of natural daily rhythms and culture. People talking about it at work. People at the next table at the restaurant chatting about a new song or movie. Knowing all your friends have an opinion about the same movie or TV show right now when the episode aired, not two years from now when they finally binge the series. THAT is what we need to figure out how to replicate. Not more niche sources/silos for hearing or buying music.

I see those paragraphs of all the niche music sites and my soul drops. I don’t want more work. I want more osmosis. I want more annoying monoculture. Spotify isn’t the problem. Paying artists, yes, they are the problem. That needs to be solved. But the BIGGER problem is re-elevating music and media to where we are all experiencing the same media at the same time,

There is definitely a FEELING in the air that is fueling this return to Physical Media. We want the tactile, visceral nature of Physical Media, but I contend that it’s the Scarcity. Monculture that we are actually craving. We all want to share the experience of looking at the cover of an album and reading the liner notes or watching the same episodes of a show at the same time.

I can do the work of prioritizing buying merch from my favorite artists. I can get one hat or one shirt every year or a physical copy of one of their newer albums that I don’t like any of the songs on, but I’ll buy the physical copy to support them. But I have a couple hundred artists that I have robust playlists for. I don’t have the money to support more than a couple of them this way. But this is really the only way that Osmosis Exposure can occur. I can wear a t-shirt of an indie band I have discovered, and that’s how others will know I like them. If I start posting about them on social media, people start unfollowing me, because no one wants to be directly told about someone’s music. It only works if it’s by osmosis. If we organically discover and assimilate the music.

tldr: Niche music sites only compound the loneliness problem. The only thing that solves this problem is restoring the Scarcity Monoculture where you don’t have any choice (or very limited choice) in the media you consume.

7 months ago
No one buys booksCreator Economy · 22 Apr 2024

As it pertains to this article, libraries ARE the current Netflix of Books. I believe that the bigger umbrella reality is that as a modern society we have been conditioned to realize that you do not HAVE to own or directly pay for a specific unit of entertainment to be able to experience it. We've eliminated the idea of life-long FOMO. Odds are great that at any time, I can go to my library or log into my Libby account and check out just about any book I want. I can confirm this, as all the books I've read the past couple of years have been via Libby. At worst, I've had to wait a week or two for the book to become available. And this has included both brand new titles as well as classics. The NEED to have the book on your shelf for when that day comes that you finally choose to read it... doesn't exist anymore. I'm typing this from my office. If at this exact moment I hear about a book and want to start reading it, I can do so from my office chair without ever having had to go to a store or to my home bookshelf. The fear of missing out on reading that book is gone. Just like with most movie titles. Over the past decade, there have only been a couple of movies I wanted to watch that I could not find on any streaming service or in my library's physical DVD collection.

Books have become almost entirely a luxury item or hobby/collector item. It's for those who have the space for a collection. If you aren't a collector or gripped by FOMO, what is the average person's reason for buying a book in 2024? How big a draw is seeing that book on one's bookshelf versus the hassle of buying the book, and then lugging it around the rest of your life when you MIGHT read it once?

I think most people are okay with the risk of not owning physical media, despite the hyperbolic articles talking about vinyl collectors or DVD/Blu-Ray collectors. When literally the ENTIRETY of mankind's books/music/TV/movie output is available at one's fingertips, instantly, the need to own this stuff evaporates. Note that this is an entirely different conversation than the dangers of streaming media suddenly vanishing overnight, along with the access to all of mankind's creations. In a perfect world, everyone has home libraries and reveres physical media. But the reality is that we live in the world where we honestly don't HAVE to own any of it. I think it's a lost cause trying to hold on to the romantic history of physical books being a foundational reality for most people. The energy should be spent on figuring out how to make READING valuable, and being part of an active discussion or community about what one is reading something that drives engagement.

I don't know if that's serialized writing, or 1000 Fans, or pure self-publishing, but I feel clinging to the romance of physical books and making those the barometer of success is the recipe for disaster. RIP Encyclopedia salesmen and 2.5 newspaper outlets every week (and nearly 3000 since 2005).

23 Apr 2024 · 5 likes

If we can unwrap our expectations of being the next unicorn (Rowling, Sanderson, Maas, Meyer, Riordan, Collins, Martin), I think that's the only way going forward. Your GOAL should be to sell 1000 copies of your book that you publish yourself. Your goal should be 1000 fans that you have identified and cultivated. If 1000 copies isn't enough to make writing a book worthwhile, then doing so will be a complete waste of your time.

But I think going forward, the only way anyone will get to whatever the next level of success looks like will be to first find their 1000 fans. IF you truly have an interesting idea, and an interesting way of presenting it, I believe it'll find its audience. If that true audience is bigger than 1000 fans, it'll expand accordingly.

At the same time, this is going to mean that 98% of the books out there will be glorified second drafts, in dire need of multiple revisions. The books that gain traction will be able to do those next drafts with real editors. I think we're just going to be in an era coming up where we have to be first enamored with the world or characters or storytelling at its most basic level, and willing to overlook that last 10 to 30% that makes it 'professional'.

As someone writing my magnum opus, I have no idea what the process of getting it out in the world is going to look like by the time I finish it. Obviously being here on Substack, I have a basic plan (serialized chapters at first), but the reality is going to be the weary task of seeking out where my potential readers might be and making them aware of my book.

As bleak as this article may be, I actually look at it as an incredible positive. It means that if your likely best-case traditional publishing outcome is 1000 copies, then you have nothing to lose by sticking to your guns and writing your own unique story in the way you want, without conforming it to the demands of what the marketplace SEEMS to indicate is mandatory. I believe it's only going to be truly unique voices and original ideas that break out of the sludge pile. If I'm going to fail anyway, I might as well go down writing a book that's 100% the story I want to tell.

22 Apr 2024 · 46 likes
Shelf

Nothing collected yet.

Collected essays

No essays collected yet.