I’ve been thinking about this article all week.
I agree that rich people are not any more naturally predisposed to be “the problem” any more than anyone else. If the problem is our propensity to stomp all over each other’s dignity and rights the second we get a little power over them, rich people just happen to be in a position to act most brazenly on it.
(As the film points out, those who grow up getting stepped on and break into the top tier of society often are among the worst offenders of abuse, because they carry vivid scars from their experience and see keeping others down as a matter of self preservation. When I think of billionaires who insist on accumulating even more wealth, I think of them as having some form of this mental illness).
What I push back on is the notion that this way of defining “status” is natural and inescapable. While I believe that humans will always want to be respected and loved by other members of their community, it hasn’t always been the case that said “status” has to come from wealth or power accumulation. (For now, I’m gonna label such status orientation as “capitalism,” which, implied in its name, grants the highest status to who can accumulate the most capital).
I am optimistic that as more and more people do inner psychological and spiritual work, accumulating more wealth and power than you need (especially if you lord it over others) will be seen as basic and gauche, in the same way that today many younger people seem look down on transparently flashing material possessions (ex. a sports car), as transparent insecure boomer shit. I realize this is a long-term project that won’t be solved by a policy decision, but I’m sincerely optimistic that it’s the next step of human evolution and that we’re well on our way (after all, we’ve more or less managed to stop glorifying and rewarding outright physical violence).
There have been cases in history where the highest “status” is instead conferred to people who display self-sacrifice and put others first, and no I don’t mean just cutting a check with a modest % of your earnings (the earliest incarnation of most major religions, certain indigenous communities, and certain anarchist communities come to mind). Yes, a “pecking order” is inescapable, but we can still refine pecking orders that are better for our happiness and for the planet around us.
Which then makes me think that perhaps rich people ARE the problem in at least one sense—since we’ve been socialized to look up to them as those who set values and trends, they perpetuate the mimetic desire to build up your sense of self-worth through accumulating wealth, one-upmanship, and displays of power over other people. So, while I believe in everyone’s inherent right to dignity and life, mercilessly mocking the very behaviors and games that used to bring rich people respect, making it socially untenable to be liked while hoarding wealth—I think that’s good for the world (not to mention, lots of fun).